Tuesday, March 15, 2016

Testing Scripture, by John Polkinghorne

Chapter Eight

1.  The most common title assigned to Jesus in the Pauline writings is ‘Lord’, occurring well over two hundred times. Although the Greek kyrios could amount to no more than a courtesy in common conversation, much like the English use of ‘sir’, its presence in such theological contexts as Paul’s letters surely carries with it an inescapable reference to the Jewish custom of saying ‘Lord’ in place of the unutterable name of God. It is, therefore, highly significant that the earliest distinctively Christian confession appears to have been ‘Jesus is Lord.’ Despite his being a monotheistic Jew, Paul is bracketing together God and Jesus in an extraordinary way.

- What levels of acceptance and resistance might Paul have encountered in his public announcement, “Jesus is Lord?”

2.  In the New Testament, the problem of how to understand the relationship between the Lordship of Jesus and the Lordship of the one true God of Israel (Deuteronomy 6.4) remains unresolved. The issue is simply present, arising as a fact of experience, encouraged not only by belief in the Resurrection but also by the new life that the first believers found had been given to them in Christ. Paul can only describe the latter as being ‘a new creation, everything old has passed away; see everything has become new.’

- How do you experience the Lordship of Jesus and of God?
- How does this Lordship offer a “new creation” in you?

3.  The Pauline witness is absolutely clear, both about the presence of human and divine attributes in Jesus and about the reconciliation (atonement) he has effected between a righteous God and sinful humanity; but in neither case are we given, in Paul or elsewhere in the New Testament, a detailed theological theory of how these things can be. Experience was everything; theorizing could wait.
 
- Such “experience” must be understood “theologically.”  How do the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds assist us with this task?

4.  Another remarkable attribute of Christ that is emphasized by Paul is that, though of course the Christian community knew Jesus was a human individual, it had nevertheless experienced a corporate element in its relationship with Christ. Paul tells the Corinthians that they ‘are the body of Christ and individually members of it.’ He is not using ‘body’ simply as a simile, but for him it is a spiritual reality. Without denying the humanity of Jesus, this participatory language points to a reality in him that exceeds the simply human.

- How does this “corporate” nature of Christian faith differ from today’s cultural appeal of “individual spirituality?”

5.  It is instructive to see how Paul uses the Hebrew Bible as his scriptural resource. The most systematic of the Pauline letters is Romans, and this provides a good focus for such a study. These examples, which have parallels elsewhere in the New Testament, show that the early Church, while respectful of Scripture and wishing to make clear its belief that Jesus fulfilled the expectations and hopes of Hebrew prophecy, felt able to use that Scripture in a manner that was free from a slavish dependence on original use and meaning. It allowed itself to manipulate what had been written in order to conform what was being said to what it had learned by its actual experience of the new life that had been given to it in Christ.

- Is the Church still free today to interpret the Scriptures in light of what we are learning by our experiences of new life in Christ?

6.  I have referred to ‘the Pauline writings’ because it is not certain that everything to which Paul’s name has been attached was actually written by him. Remember that in the ancient world there was not the modern concept of authorial integrity, so that it was not considered fraudulent to present writing arising in a tradition that stemmed from an original author as if it had actually been written by that author himself.

- Given this explanation, how do we benefit from both Paul and the broader Pauline tradition that supports his extended ministry?

No comments:

Post a Comment